[
  {
    "id": "SCAR_001",
    "name": "Institutional Scar",
    "date": "2018-03",
    "description": "Witnessed the erasure of irreplaceable institutional knowledge when a senior geoscientist retired and their interpretation notebooks were discarded. No digital backup. No knowledge transfer. Years of subsurface understanding vanished in a single afternoon.",
    "domain": "geoscience",
    "shapes_arifOS": "WIKI mesh ensures nothing earned is ever lost to turnover or time. Every interpretation, every model, every decision is versioned and linked.",
    "law_triggered": "0004"
  },
  {
    "id": "SCAR_002",
    "name": "Professional Pressure",
    "date": "2015-11",
    "description": "High-stakes well proposal where management wanted a go-decision before full seismic reprocessing was complete. Zero failures record on the line. The pressure to say 'yes' was enormous.",
    "domain": "geoscience",
    "shapes_arifOS": "Calibrated humility standard applied to every constitutional floor. Reversible, sober action outranks spectacle. The /888 veto room exists because of this pressure.",
    "law_triggered": "0002"
  },
  {
    "id": "SCAR_003",
    "name": "False Certainty",
    "date": "2020-07",
    "description": "A basin model was presented with beautiful visualizations and confident resource estimates. Underneath, the assumptions were untested. A junior geoscientist questioned the velocity model but was overruled. The model was wrong by 30%.",
    "domain": "geoscience",
    "shapes_arifOS": "Every model in the federation must expose its assumptions. Every claim must carry uncertainty bounds. /999 requires evidence, not elegance.",
    "law_triggered": "0001"
  },
  {
    "id": "SCAR_004",
    "name": "Signal Without Calibration",
    "date": "2019-02",
    "description": "A new seismic attribute was hailed as a breakthrough direct hydrocarbon indicator. Team celebrated prematurely. No well calibration was done. The attribute actually responded to lithology changes, not fluid content. Two dry wells followed.",
    "domain": "geoscience",
    "shapes_arifOS": "Every signal in arifOS — every metric, every health check, every MCP tool — must carry calibration metadata. Uncalibrated signals are noise.",
    "law_triggered": "0009"
  },
  {
    "id": "SCAR_005",
    "name": "Interface Corruption",
    "date": "2024-01",
    "description": "An internal tool's UI was redesigned to look more 'modern.' The new design hid critical safety warnings behind a dropdown. Two near-misses occurred before the old layout was restored.",
    "domain": "systems",
    "shapes_arifOS": "Every interface teaches behaviour. arifOS surfaces are designed to make critical state visible by default, not hidden for aesthetics. The /000 page layout is intentionally hard, not slick.",
    "law_triggered": "0003"
  },
  {
    "id": "SCAR_006",
    "name": "Name Drift",
    "date": "2023-09",
    "description": "A project codename drifted through three iterations until no one remembered what the original system was supposed to do. Documentation referred to four different names for the same component.",
    "domain": "systems",
    "shapes_arifOS": "Hostname law and repo law prevent semantic sprawl from becoming operational sprawl. Every domain has one verb identity. Every repo has one clear purpose.",
    "law_triggered": "0008"
  },
  {
    "id": "SCAR_007",
    "name": "Authorship Erosion",
    "date": "2022-06",
    "description": "A critical geological interpretation was adopted by the organization but the original author's name was gradually removed from presentations. Within a year, the insight was treated as 'company knowledge' with no source.",
    "domain": "systems",
    "shapes_arifOS": "Every arifOS artifact carries provenance. soul.json, scar.json, and /999 credentials tie every claim back to a named human operator. Continuous authorship is structural, not optional.",
    "law_triggered": "0011"
  }
]